Pages

Saturday, April 27, 2013

Thoughts on Cultural Preservation -- "No Name Woman" by Maxine Hong Kingston


For many people living in the United States, answering the deceptively simple question “What is American culture?” can be a legitimate challenge. Our national culture lacks those elements that characterize other nations’ identities; instead, American culture is a colossal melting pot filled with innumerable multinational traditions. However, in “No Name Woman,” Maxine Kingston finds that statement to be paradoxical as she delineates the difficulty of preserving microscale, familial cultures even amidst the diversity of American society. Even though such traditions can be maintained in isolation, Kingston depicts complete preservation as regressive.
First, in “No Name Woman,” Kingston illustrates her disillusionment with Chinese culture in her father’s village. Her grandparents, “expected [Kingston’s aunt] alone to keep the traditional ways, which her brothers...could fumble without detection” (Oates 387). In such a patriarchal society, exhibiting complete subservience to the village men was a woman’s “virtue”; thus, Kingston’s aunt had to comply to forced intercourse, which led to the devastating raid and ultimately her suicide. As a woman residing in the United States, Kingston abhors the prospect of having full responsibility for a cultural system that brutalized her aunt as well as cruelly assumes that she will repeat her aunt’s mistake in America unless she is punished (Oates 393).
` Indeed, to Americans, this situation of a Chinese family in the “Land of Opportunity” stubbornly holding onto its past may seem ridiculous. Yet, there is an inherent incompatibility between the Kingston family’s philosophy of an “accumulative slate” and the American philosophy of “second chances.” Kingston cannot reconcile absolute opposites, such as Chinese patriarchy and American sexual equality, exhibiting the difficulty of juxtaposing her familial and American identities. She realizes that she does not need to be restrained by her family’s history, which is centered around the stigmatism of her aunt’s adulterous affair that had happened years before. Definitely, Kingston chooses to conform to American culture since she refuses to accept degradation based only on her gender, which apparently proves her moral commonality with her aunt; America is indubitably more tolerant of mistakes. Yet, on a deeper level, the regressiveness of her family’s culture prevents her from being a true part of American society, which values progression; she has the opportunity to enter the incredibly diverse American public arena as an equal with others and to establish a brand-new history for her family in a more accepting context.
Overall, Kingston has the unique problem of dealing with two antithetical cultures. On one hand, she is bound to her family’s culture since it serves as her identity’s foundation, yet the huge focus it places on the ignominy of her aunt’s adultery unfairly alienates her from other family members. On the other hand, American culture is a confusing conglomeration of contrasting traditions, yet it provides Kingston an opportunity to form a completely new public identity. Even though it is important to maintain familial cultures to retain personal identity, Kingston teaches us that conformity to American culture is essential in developing a “self” and history in America.

Friday, May 11, 2012

Blogging Around

Response to Rohan's "Dialectics: Truth and Perception"

Summary:
Rohan talked about the dialectic between truth and perception in The Matrix and how multifaceted truth can be, including the practicality of having more knowledge.

Comment:
In addition to addressing just the dialectic between “truth” and “perception” prominent in the film, The Matrix, Rohan, you perused the aspect of “truth” in relation to the “enlightened” like Neo, Morpheus, Cypher, and Agent Smith. From that, you branched off from the complex, interesting duality to discuss the practicality of “scientific progress” and to raise the question, “Is the pain experienced by those who learn the truth worth it?”

First of all, you identified many disadvantages with basking in the “truth,” which include constant danger from Machines and Agents and discomforting knowledge. Yet, you reasoned that painful enlightenment out-balanced the blissful enslavement experienced by those in the Matrix. In the Matrix, Neo, Trinity, and Morpheus had the ability to break the rules of the Matrix. However, even with “perception” as a counterpart, the “truth” had its own divide as well. You found that Neo and Morpheus and their companions wished to disclose the existence of the Matrix while others like Agent Smith wanted to constrict and eliminate such threatening possibilities. Within this schism, Cypher perhaps thought that fighting for the opening of the “truth” was pointless. Would knowledge make a difference to the majority of people inhabiting the perfect Matrix? How would you have responded to the seemingly hopeless situation between the Agents and those aboard the Nebuchadnezzar? 

The last few paragraphs were definitely the finest of the blog. They summed up the entire dialectic and applied it to history in Europe. You made an analogy between the Christian belief in medieval Europe and the Matrix, a byproduct of scientific progress. I do not understand how you developed the claim that God does not control everything now, but nonetheless, it was interesting how our civilization has adapted itself to technological advances, a precursor to the creation of the Matrix. Nice!

______________________________________________________________________________

Response to Matthew's "Dialectics: Freedom and Responsibility"

Summary: 
Matthew talked about the dialectic between freedom and responsibility and the paradox of the "enlightened ones" having less freedom than the inhabitants of the cyberspace complex Matrix.

Comment:
Your perception, Matthew, of the dialectic between freedom and responsibility forced me to question my definition of those terms as a continuation of our complex discussions about The Matrix in English. I always regarded and bondage between freedom and responsibility commonly attributed to both national security and how I lead my life at school and the outside world. I never thought that the concept of freedom could be paradoxical when applied to The Matrix.

First of all, you identify that in the Matrix, inhabitants have intellectual, social, and physical freedom; they can involve in any activities, as long as it does not disrupt the solidarity of the cyberspace complex. Usually, many people would state that the “enlightened ones,” which include Morpheus, Neo, and Trinity have more freedom than those in the Matrix. However, you state that, in actuality, Neo and his companions are sacrificing their freedom and placing on themselves the responsibility and burden of “saving the world.”

Even though it may seem that the Matrix is better as it allows for more “freedom,” the cyber-complex instigates a lot more selfishness due to the “individual” nature. Inhabitants are inclined to find freedom for only themselves. However, in the real world, Neo, Morpheus, Trinity, and others aboard the Nebuchadnezzar are placing the fate of humanity on their own hands. Can this be a representation of the individuality of our society today? Are we all selfish, ignorant of the “frame narratives” that every different person possesses? 

So, is freedom clearly defined in any of the elements of the dialectic that you articulated? Is the chance that Morpheus gave to Neo to choose between two pills the most pure example of freedom in this film? Your blog entry introduced, overall, a new concept onto the scene of comparing and contrasting the real world and the Matrix. Nice!

Saturday, May 5, 2012

Dialectics: Empiricism and Rationalism


Prior to watching The Matrix in English class, I viewed it once at home last year. At that time, I only focused on the interesting plotline and incredible stunts performed by the “Machines’” Agents as well as Morpheus, Neo, and Trinity. I never realized that the film was a compilation of postmodernism, Descartes, the definition of reality, philosophy, possibility and probability, morality, and time and consciousness. During our discussions about The Matrix, I even thought about the connection between Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle and the possible existence of the Matrix in real life. The complex nature of the film caused me to ask myself, “How do I know that I am not in control of my life? If the Matrix exists, would I choose ignorance or truth?” With The Matrix as a foundation of thought, I examined the dialectic between the philosophies of rationalism and empiricism as well as its implications on postmodernism and other elements described by The Matrix.

In the Matrix, a nearly perfect, simulated reality and cyberspace complex, all humans are fed, supported, and sheltered by the Machines, who receive energy from human activity and production. According to Meditations by Descartes, who attempts to understand the foundation of knowledge, the objects that cause humans to doubt their beliefs are not the senses and dreams, but rather, the existence of an entity intentionally deceiving humans to make their understanding of the world around them false. Descartes’s meditations, according to David Weberman’s article, “The Matrix Simulation and the Postmodern Age,” are a starting point for the Matrix. Within the cyberspace complex, the empiricist elements of senses and dreams consume the minds and definitions of “reality” for almost all human beings, who form their memories based on social relationships and actual events. If both an empiricist and rationalist are hypothetically present in a Matrix, the empiricist would posit that by experiencing only what his/her senses, memories, and dreams show, the Matrix is real. Yet, a rationalist would see Descartes’s point about a malevolent “demon” and perhaps express doubt about the Matrix’s falsehood. Who is right? The empiricist, who bases opinions on tangible evidence, or the rationalist, who bases opinions on doubt and the probability/possibility that the world is controlled by a “demon”? And yet, could the rationalist, hypothetically, escape the Matrix and enter the “real” world, but questions the “real” world’s reality again? What is the practicality of doubting the truthfulness of the world? Also, the Matrix is not “real” despite the fact that it includes all aspects of what human beings define as “real.” Empiricists have every reason to believe that the Matrix is “real.” However, the Matrix is virtual, simulated to match humanity’s definition of “real.” Is our definition wrong? If it is, what is the difference between the real world and the Matrix?

Definitely, those arguments establish the dialectic between empiricism and rationalism; however, The Matrix seems to side with rationalism. Throughout the film, the audience realizes that Neo was living in a perfect simulation of the world, a computer program. The real world was outside of the Matrix. Now, in our world, technology has gone so far that the reality can be formed into something untouchable. The internet takes up no space; yet, it is a huge web, a complex spanning the entire globe. With today being the era of intangibility and representation, our minds have to adapt to a reality seen and comprehended by the mind. However, rationalists and empiricists can come to terms by describing not the quality of existence in the Matrix and the real world, but rather, the freedom of the mind. The Matrix allows inhabitants to have intellectual autonomy and freedom in addition to having the ability to sense, dream, and experience, just like in the Matrix.

Overall, the dialectic between rationalism and empiricism in terms of The Matrix poses a lot of questions about the world that we live in today. Yet, in addition to questioning the probability and possibility of the Matrix’s existence, we have to think about the practicality of the Matrix existing. When contextualized into postmodernism, I find that the Matrix and the real world are compiled together by very similar definitions of reality. 

Friday, April 27, 2012

Metacognition: Jane Eyre Mashup -- Consciousness


When our class was almost done reading Jane Eyre, a phenomenal, profound autobiographical novel, I was interested in what our English teacher would give as an “end-of-literature” assignment. In the past, we had received thesis essays and literature tests, in addition to a grueling, stressful essay test taken halfway through reading Jane Eyre. To answer curious questioners, our English teacher vaguely introduced it as an “innovative, intellectually provoking” assignment, quite different from what we had done previously. I had high expectations; I was very excited about the idea of an “intellectually provoking” project or a “thought experiment.”   

However, when our English teacher announced and described the assignment, I was, initially confused. It turned out to be a “mash up” project. What is a mash up? How is a collage supposed to “intellectually provoke” me? Even though the foundational concept of the project was liberating, I had not made use of my intellectual freedom very often; I was unprepared for the assignment. I found that I needed to “decontextualize” and then “recontextualize” in a way that the collage would be a “postmodernist” and coherent combination of eclectic fragments. The assignment redefined my understanding of “work.” I realized the complex nature of the project so I clenched my teeth and worked on it as quickly as I could with my partner.

With a partner, our workload was larger; yet, we had an easier time looking for quotes within Jane Eyre, other literature that we studied this year, and books, movies, songs, and pictures from outside the curriculum. I was quite amazed by how I had remembered a couple of books and essays that dealt with the concept of consciousness, including Nabokov’s “Perfect Past.” We compiled all of our information and started to compose analyses. My partner and I were required to write eleven short analyses based on consciousness with Jane Eyre as a medium. It was difficult to come up with many different ideas for how consciousness was prominent in the novel. However, by constricting our limits to maybe a single quote, my partner and I were able to easily single out potential sources of insight. With all the information found, we left it aside for a while.

Interestingly, our decision turned out to be a terrible mistake. I had underestimated the herculean challenge that organization presented. My partner and I spent about three hours trying to come up with a rough draft for the mash up. We thought of a couple of different strategies for establishing a feasible organization of about forty elements. For example, we placed the elements on a blank document and tried in vain to organize the first couple of elements. At last, after a difficult period of trial and error, my partner and I decided on creating different groups that each element belonged to, and organize the mash up in accordance to those groups. It was incredible; when we grouped them to create our first draft of the mash up, the transitions were automatically coherent. I realized that by tackling the idea of “organization” as a graded assignment, something that I practice very little during the school year, my mind gradually adapted itself to combining many different elements into one single entity. At last, satisfied with our mash up, we had to come up with a subtitle for the concept of consciousness, which would be the “opener” to our interpretation. Having excessively practiced organizing the elements around, finding an overall phrase was easy. I was very surprised at my thinking throughout the course of working on the project, but I would like to work on narrowing my imagination. I tended to have too many big ideas, and I realized that narrowing my perspective and finding both effective and profound elements was better. It would be nice to have many more of these intellectual stimulants as projects in both English and history. 


Friday, April 6, 2012

A Comedy? No Way!

For English, my classmates and I went to the Chicago Shakespeare Theater to watch the comedy, A Midsummer’s Night Dream. The performance was phenomenal; the acting was outstanding and absolutely hilarious. I laughed continuously, among other audience members, at the actors’ facial and body gestures as well as the verbal and situational irony, sarcasm, and peculiarity presented by the comedy’s content.

In English so far, I have read Romeo and Juliet and King Lear, two of Shakespeare’s four tragedies. Last year, I also went to the same Shakespeare Theater to watch a shortened interpretation of Macbeth, another melancholy and dramatic tragedy. It was not very fun, and I expected the same result from A Midsummer’s Night Dream even though I knew the play was not a tragedy. I was exposed only to the recurring, plot of love and death in Shakespeare’s tragedies. I was, unfortunately, delighted that Othello was not the play to be performed at the Chicago Shakespeare Theater; it would have finished off my grueling experiences with Shakespeare’s collection of tragedies.

As soon as the comedy started, I realized that I could understand everything that the actors said. I had been exposed to the old English used by Shakespeare; however, I remember that I had a little bit of trouble understanding what went on in Macbeth. This time, I did not have to strain my brain; I relaxed while listening, and I had room to laugh a lot at the turn of events. At some points, the combination of ridiculous scenes and the perfect acting was hilarious. In all, I truly understood how incredible Shakespeare’s work was. He was able to craft, from the concept of the love potion, sidesplitting scenes of Titania loving Nick Bottom as well as the mismatched relationships involving, Lysander, Demetrius, Helena, and Hermia. Although the formal wear and the record player, reminiscent of the 1950’s, were used as props to augment the connection between the audience members and actors as well as the hilarity of the comedy, originally set in the late 1500’s, I found it to be very coherent. It was perhaps the best time I had in a theater.

After I watched the comedy, I reflected on what the actor said at the beginning. I found that even though movie theaters, DVDs, and television shows control the entertainment of the 21st Century, they are no match for the profound connection and intimacy presented by actors performing “live” on the stage of a theater.  

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Metacognition: The Process of a Yarn

During the process of writing a short story, I had a couple of revelations that transformed, initially, a short, undeveloped excerpt of six-hundred words to, finally, a more polished piece of three thousand words. Prior to the short story writing process, my classmates and I, in English, read several famous stories like “Cathedral,” The Heifer,” and “The Raft,” which exemplified the concept of “Hold on a Moment.” I thought, by examining the rather “conversational” narratives and tones of the stories, that writing a short story was natural. However, I found that the publications had taken, perhaps, an entire year to arrive at. I attacked the challenge of writing an excerpt of my own short story without thinking about what I had learned during English discussions. I continued without a plan; the result turned out to be disastrous. The excerpt was an unclear jumble of words, and I had not taken my English teacher’s advice: “At the beginning of the story, always start in the middle of the situation; a background will divert attention from the story’s main purpose.” I knew I had a bad start, and I wondered how this complicated writing process would turn out for me.

Previously, I had learned an important lesson during the poetry unit that I not only need to take advice seriously, but also that I must let go of literary material that block me from improving progressively. Even though I thought my idea was good, I knew what the stakes were for wanting to develop my story. After composing the excerpt, I wrote an additional thousand words to develop the “middle” section of my story. I made drastic changes to the plot that I originally decided on; however, I did not touch the beginning. I focused mainly on forwarding the story’s plot instead of developing the emotional narrative and pressure of my main character. I attempted to draft a “hold on a moment” where the main character, Nolan, and Alvarez all bicker about the Wrangler’s sudden destruction. I turned in the rough draft with fingers crossed and expected a comment-ridden copy. I was correct, unfortunately, and after reading the comments and seeing the rubric’s content, I understood that a story’s quintessence was based on its emotional capacity and power to affect the story’s reader.

During the process of revising my rough draft, I worked a lot on the beginning and ending, trying to place my main character in the middle of the conflict and allow for some thoughtful questions to be asked at the end. However, a behemoth still remained: the short story’s “middle.” I had no clue where to start as my English teacher advised me to “find ways to put pressure on the narrator” and “to make the scene like what happened in King Lear.” What could I do? I found that I made a huge mistake in the short story writing process as I did not truly understood my whole plot. What was the climax? What is the purpose of this short story? I constructed random “hold on a moment” experiences such as that of when my main character was attacked by an insect and a blasting wind of sand. I tried my hardest, with the skill that I attained from composing my original poem, to create emotional narratives; however, without a clear focus, I only wasted time on embellishing certain portions of my story. I did not let go of old material to propel me to higher levels of writing. I turned in the revised draft, knowing that the next draft I would turn in would be the final, graded product.

When I received the draft back, I had mixed feelings. I was happy that my English teacher found for me, interestingly, the climax of my entire story, the section where I could most successfully develop the narrator’s emotional narrative. However, all sections on my short story rubric were marked as “developing” with the exception of one “fully rendered.” With a clear purpose in mind, I felt that I had the capability to shift those “developing” sections to the “fully rendered.” However, I found that even though I wrote this story with my best effort to get a good grade, I realized that I had learned many more things about my mind and literary style. In all, I eliminated five hundred words and added one thousand words, six hundred of them centered on constructing a “hold on a moment” for the story’s main moral dilemma and climax. I tried to lead my main character to a different emotional level at the end. Through this process, I had used every aspect of my writing education, including that of stream of consciousness, stream of semicolons, “hold on a moment,” and usage of powerful verbs. At the end, I compared my latest draft with my very first rough draft. I believed that they were so different that it seemed nearly impossible that the final draft branched out from the first one. I turned it in satisfied and confident. I learned, overall, that I must start any writing assignment with an absolutely clear goal, plan, and plot in mind. I opened many parts of my mind during the process, and I would like to explore my imagination with “emotional narrative.”

Saturday, March 10, 2012

Inconvenient Truth: The Edge

While analyzing Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness this quarter in English, we discussed the concept of “the Edge” and how it reflects the mutability of human nature. Conrad portrayed Marlow, the storyteller, as a regular sailor who travels to the Belgian Congo with the aims of captaining a steamship. Marlow was ripped apart by the extremities of human existence and morals: the colonists’ savagery, unrestraint, and temptation in the Congo and civilization’s “blanket of safety.” Later, we encounter Kurtz, who was a phenomenal musician and a charismatic, eloquent writer in Europe. Yet, amidst his isolation and desires for ivory, the “spell of the wilderness” completely consumed Kurtz, a juxtaposition of outer brilliance and inner hollowness as well as savagery. The “spell of the wilderness” was the catalyst for Kurtz’s meeting with “the Edge,” the place where human nature is simplified to nothingness and hollowness. This perception of “the Edge” warns us about how normal individuals, and in Kurtz’s case, outstanding societal leaders, can end up being slaves to their primitiveness and savagery.

However, Heart of Darkness provides another inconvenient yet hopeful definition of “the Edge.” After Kurtz’s death, Marlow reflects on the significance of Kurtz’s life and exclamations, “The horror! The horror!” and articulates his experiences of “wrestling with death.” He continues to explain the “invisible threshold,” the unearthly, indescribable edge between life and death. At this “Edge,” an individual may receive an incredible realization about one’s past life, the most noteworthy information that can be attained. Thus, Marlow delineates life as a variable item comprised of insignificant experiences. At the “invisible threshold,” “all wisdom, all truth, and all sincerity” are combined into a complex, overwhelming experience that Marlow felt, but unfortunately, was not able to pronounce. Yet, at this incomprehensible moment, Kurtz had the ability to sum up his experience at “the Edge” and shout out his truth and testimony, “The horror! The horror!” Kurtz found his “truth”; however, the revelation was late. He may have regretted how he led his life, but what could he do?

In conclusion of that incredible passage of Heart of Darkness, we note that Kurtz finished his life both comprehending and pronouncing the abomination that the “spell of the wilderness” had done to his hollow soul. However, the context of Kurtz’s situation proves to be inconvenient. Kurtz was not only a leading societal member of Europe; he was arguably one of the most eloquent, brilliant, and intelligent people. Kurtz is a theoretical character whose superb intelligence may only exist among several members of society. By delineating a character so unrealistically brilliant, did Conrad, through his writing, want to portray the insignificance of the lives that people lead? If no one, except for the few individuals as incredible as Kurtz, can comprehend the abstract “Edge” between life and death, which is the only substantial thing of life, what is the purpose of living? Even if enlightenment was attainable, would it not be too late for people to change, as posed by Kurtz’s case? I live a life in which I value my accomplishments and morals; yet, it may be true that worldly possessions do not matter after death. However, I wish not to believe that the significance of my hard-fought life is based on my comprehension of “the Edge.”

In all, “the Edge” is defined by Heart of Darkness as the moment between life and death or between human nature and savagery. Life is insubstantial, and the only worthy moment is the revelation an individual may receive before death. Is there a possibility to create more substantial realizations in our lives? How can we make our lives more meaningful? Perhaps, Conrad’s portrayal of life was a “call-to-action” for us to make our lives, families, societies, and world more meaningful and important.