Pages

Friday, May 11, 2012

Blogging Around

Response to Rohan's "Dialectics: Truth and Perception"

Summary:
Rohan talked about the dialectic between truth and perception in The Matrix and how multifaceted truth can be, including the practicality of having more knowledge.

Comment:
In addition to addressing just the dialectic between “truth” and “perception” prominent in the film, The Matrix, Rohan, you perused the aspect of “truth” in relation to the “enlightened” like Neo, Morpheus, Cypher, and Agent Smith. From that, you branched off from the complex, interesting duality to discuss the practicality of “scientific progress” and to raise the question, “Is the pain experienced by those who learn the truth worth it?”

First of all, you identified many disadvantages with basking in the “truth,” which include constant danger from Machines and Agents and discomforting knowledge. Yet, you reasoned that painful enlightenment out-balanced the blissful enslavement experienced by those in the Matrix. In the Matrix, Neo, Trinity, and Morpheus had the ability to break the rules of the Matrix. However, even with “perception” as a counterpart, the “truth” had its own divide as well. You found that Neo and Morpheus and their companions wished to disclose the existence of the Matrix while others like Agent Smith wanted to constrict and eliminate such threatening possibilities. Within this schism, Cypher perhaps thought that fighting for the opening of the “truth” was pointless. Would knowledge make a difference to the majority of people inhabiting the perfect Matrix? How would you have responded to the seemingly hopeless situation between the Agents and those aboard the Nebuchadnezzar? 

The last few paragraphs were definitely the finest of the blog. They summed up the entire dialectic and applied it to history in Europe. You made an analogy between the Christian belief in medieval Europe and the Matrix, a byproduct of scientific progress. I do not understand how you developed the claim that God does not control everything now, but nonetheless, it was interesting how our civilization has adapted itself to technological advances, a precursor to the creation of the Matrix. Nice!

______________________________________________________________________________

Response to Matthew's "Dialectics: Freedom and Responsibility"

Summary: 
Matthew talked about the dialectic between freedom and responsibility and the paradox of the "enlightened ones" having less freedom than the inhabitants of the cyberspace complex Matrix.

Comment:
Your perception, Matthew, of the dialectic between freedom and responsibility forced me to question my definition of those terms as a continuation of our complex discussions about The Matrix in English. I always regarded and bondage between freedom and responsibility commonly attributed to both national security and how I lead my life at school and the outside world. I never thought that the concept of freedom could be paradoxical when applied to The Matrix.

First of all, you identify that in the Matrix, inhabitants have intellectual, social, and physical freedom; they can involve in any activities, as long as it does not disrupt the solidarity of the cyberspace complex. Usually, many people would state that the “enlightened ones,” which include Morpheus, Neo, and Trinity have more freedom than those in the Matrix. However, you state that, in actuality, Neo and his companions are sacrificing their freedom and placing on themselves the responsibility and burden of “saving the world.”

Even though it may seem that the Matrix is better as it allows for more “freedom,” the cyber-complex instigates a lot more selfishness due to the “individual” nature. Inhabitants are inclined to find freedom for only themselves. However, in the real world, Neo, Morpheus, Trinity, and others aboard the Nebuchadnezzar are placing the fate of humanity on their own hands. Can this be a representation of the individuality of our society today? Are we all selfish, ignorant of the “frame narratives” that every different person possesses? 

So, is freedom clearly defined in any of the elements of the dialectic that you articulated? Is the chance that Morpheus gave to Neo to choose between two pills the most pure example of freedom in this film? Your blog entry introduced, overall, a new concept onto the scene of comparing and contrasting the real world and the Matrix. Nice!

Saturday, May 5, 2012

Dialectics: Empiricism and Rationalism


Prior to watching The Matrix in English class, I viewed it once at home last year. At that time, I only focused on the interesting plotline and incredible stunts performed by the “Machines’” Agents as well as Morpheus, Neo, and Trinity. I never realized that the film was a compilation of postmodernism, Descartes, the definition of reality, philosophy, possibility and probability, morality, and time and consciousness. During our discussions about The Matrix, I even thought about the connection between Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle and the possible existence of the Matrix in real life. The complex nature of the film caused me to ask myself, “How do I know that I am not in control of my life? If the Matrix exists, would I choose ignorance or truth?” With The Matrix as a foundation of thought, I examined the dialectic between the philosophies of rationalism and empiricism as well as its implications on postmodernism and other elements described by The Matrix.

In the Matrix, a nearly perfect, simulated reality and cyberspace complex, all humans are fed, supported, and sheltered by the Machines, who receive energy from human activity and production. According to Meditations by Descartes, who attempts to understand the foundation of knowledge, the objects that cause humans to doubt their beliefs are not the senses and dreams, but rather, the existence of an entity intentionally deceiving humans to make their understanding of the world around them false. Descartes’s meditations, according to David Weberman’s article, “The Matrix Simulation and the Postmodern Age,” are a starting point for the Matrix. Within the cyberspace complex, the empiricist elements of senses and dreams consume the minds and definitions of “reality” for almost all human beings, who form their memories based on social relationships and actual events. If both an empiricist and rationalist are hypothetically present in a Matrix, the empiricist would posit that by experiencing only what his/her senses, memories, and dreams show, the Matrix is real. Yet, a rationalist would see Descartes’s point about a malevolent “demon” and perhaps express doubt about the Matrix’s falsehood. Who is right? The empiricist, who bases opinions on tangible evidence, or the rationalist, who bases opinions on doubt and the probability/possibility that the world is controlled by a “demon”? And yet, could the rationalist, hypothetically, escape the Matrix and enter the “real” world, but questions the “real” world’s reality again? What is the practicality of doubting the truthfulness of the world? Also, the Matrix is not “real” despite the fact that it includes all aspects of what human beings define as “real.” Empiricists have every reason to believe that the Matrix is “real.” However, the Matrix is virtual, simulated to match humanity’s definition of “real.” Is our definition wrong? If it is, what is the difference between the real world and the Matrix?

Definitely, those arguments establish the dialectic between empiricism and rationalism; however, The Matrix seems to side with rationalism. Throughout the film, the audience realizes that Neo was living in a perfect simulation of the world, a computer program. The real world was outside of the Matrix. Now, in our world, technology has gone so far that the reality can be formed into something untouchable. The internet takes up no space; yet, it is a huge web, a complex spanning the entire globe. With today being the era of intangibility and representation, our minds have to adapt to a reality seen and comprehended by the mind. However, rationalists and empiricists can come to terms by describing not the quality of existence in the Matrix and the real world, but rather, the freedom of the mind. The Matrix allows inhabitants to have intellectual autonomy and freedom in addition to having the ability to sense, dream, and experience, just like in the Matrix.

Overall, the dialectic between rationalism and empiricism in terms of The Matrix poses a lot of questions about the world that we live in today. Yet, in addition to questioning the probability and possibility of the Matrix’s existence, we have to think about the practicality of the Matrix existing. When contextualized into postmodernism, I find that the Matrix and the real world are compiled together by very similar definitions of reality.