For many people living in the United States, answering the deceptively simple question “What is American culture?” can be a legitimate challenge. Our national culture lacks those elements that characterize other nations’ identities; instead, American culture is a colossal melting pot filled with innumerable multinational traditions. However, in “No Name Woman,” Maxine Kingston finds that statement to be paradoxical as she delineates the difficulty of preserving microscale, familial cultures even amidst the diversity of American society. Even though such traditions can be maintained in isolation, Kingston depicts complete preservation as regressive.
First, in “No Name Woman,” Kingston illustrates her disillusionment with Chinese culture in her father’s village. Her grandparents, “expected [Kingston’s aunt] alone to keep the traditional ways, which her brothers...could fumble without detection” (Oates 387). In such a patriarchal society, exhibiting complete subservience to the village men was a woman’s “virtue”; thus, Kingston’s aunt had to comply to forced intercourse, which led to the devastating raid and ultimately her suicide. As a woman residing in the United States, Kingston abhors the prospect of having full responsibility for a cultural system that brutalized her aunt as well as cruelly assumes that she will repeat her aunt’s mistake in America unless she is punished (Oates 393).
` Indeed, to Americans, this situation of a Chinese family in the “Land of Opportunity” stubbornly holding onto its past may seem ridiculous. Yet, there is an inherent incompatibility between the Kingston family’s philosophy of an “accumulative slate” and the American philosophy of “second chances.” Kingston cannot reconcile absolute opposites, such as Chinese patriarchy and American sexual equality, exhibiting the difficulty of juxtaposing her familial and American identities. She realizes that she does not need to be restrained by her family’s history, which is centered around the stigmatism of her aunt’s adulterous affair that had happened years before. Definitely, Kingston chooses to conform to American culture since she refuses to accept degradation based only on her gender, which apparently proves her moral commonality with her aunt; America is indubitably more tolerant of mistakes. Yet, on a deeper level, the regressiveness of her family’s culture prevents her from being a true part of American society, which values progression; she has the opportunity to enter the incredibly diverse American public arena as an equal with others and to establish a brand-new history for her family in a more accepting context.
Overall, Kingston has the unique problem of dealing with two antithetical cultures. On one hand, she is bound to her family’s culture since it serves as her identity’s foundation, yet the huge focus it places on the ignominy of her aunt’s adultery unfairly alienates her from other family members. On the other hand, American culture is a confusing conglomeration of contrasting traditions, yet it provides Kingston an opportunity to form a completely new public identity. Even though it is important to maintain familial cultures to retain personal identity, Kingston teaches us that conformity to American culture is essential in developing a “self” and history in America.
No comments:
Post a Comment