Pages

Saturday, May 5, 2012

Dialectics: Empiricism and Rationalism


Prior to watching The Matrix in English class, I viewed it once at home last year. At that time, I only focused on the interesting plotline and incredible stunts performed by the “Machines’” Agents as well as Morpheus, Neo, and Trinity. I never realized that the film was a compilation of postmodernism, Descartes, the definition of reality, philosophy, possibility and probability, morality, and time and consciousness. During our discussions about The Matrix, I even thought about the connection between Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle and the possible existence of the Matrix in real life. The complex nature of the film caused me to ask myself, “How do I know that I am not in control of my life? If the Matrix exists, would I choose ignorance or truth?” With The Matrix as a foundation of thought, I examined the dialectic between the philosophies of rationalism and empiricism as well as its implications on postmodernism and other elements described by The Matrix.

In the Matrix, a nearly perfect, simulated reality and cyberspace complex, all humans are fed, supported, and sheltered by the Machines, who receive energy from human activity and production. According to Meditations by Descartes, who attempts to understand the foundation of knowledge, the objects that cause humans to doubt their beliefs are not the senses and dreams, but rather, the existence of an entity intentionally deceiving humans to make their understanding of the world around them false. Descartes’s meditations, according to David Weberman’s article, “The Matrix Simulation and the Postmodern Age,” are a starting point for the Matrix. Within the cyberspace complex, the empiricist elements of senses and dreams consume the minds and definitions of “reality” for almost all human beings, who form their memories based on social relationships and actual events. If both an empiricist and rationalist are hypothetically present in a Matrix, the empiricist would posit that by experiencing only what his/her senses, memories, and dreams show, the Matrix is real. Yet, a rationalist would see Descartes’s point about a malevolent “demon” and perhaps express doubt about the Matrix’s falsehood. Who is right? The empiricist, who bases opinions on tangible evidence, or the rationalist, who bases opinions on doubt and the probability/possibility that the world is controlled by a “demon”? And yet, could the rationalist, hypothetically, escape the Matrix and enter the “real” world, but questions the “real” world’s reality again? What is the practicality of doubting the truthfulness of the world? Also, the Matrix is not “real” despite the fact that it includes all aspects of what human beings define as “real.” Empiricists have every reason to believe that the Matrix is “real.” However, the Matrix is virtual, simulated to match humanity’s definition of “real.” Is our definition wrong? If it is, what is the difference between the real world and the Matrix?

Definitely, those arguments establish the dialectic between empiricism and rationalism; however, The Matrix seems to side with rationalism. Throughout the film, the audience realizes that Neo was living in a perfect simulation of the world, a computer program. The real world was outside of the Matrix. Now, in our world, technology has gone so far that the reality can be formed into something untouchable. The internet takes up no space; yet, it is a huge web, a complex spanning the entire globe. With today being the era of intangibility and representation, our minds have to adapt to a reality seen and comprehended by the mind. However, rationalists and empiricists can come to terms by describing not the quality of existence in the Matrix and the real world, but rather, the freedom of the mind. The Matrix allows inhabitants to have intellectual autonomy and freedom in addition to having the ability to sense, dream, and experience, just like in the Matrix.

Overall, the dialectic between rationalism and empiricism in terms of The Matrix poses a lot of questions about the world that we live in today. Yet, in addition to questioning the probability and possibility of the Matrix’s existence, we have to think about the practicality of the Matrix existing. When contextualized into postmodernism, I find that the Matrix and the real world are compiled together by very similar definitions of reality. 

3 comments:

  1. Daniel, this was a great entry. It really got me to think about what we define to be real and to think about the philosophies we learned both in history and in english.
    This seems to relate greatly to the brain-in-the-vat thought experiment. The brain-in-the-vat was a thought expiriment in which a brain was placed inside a vat of life-sustaining fluids and fed electrical signals simulating the act of actually living. The brain would think that it is seeing, feeling, creating, and living just as a normal human being would. However, it technically isn't- it's simply a blob of cells being fed electricity in a jar.
    Of course, this not only raises the philosophical conundrum of what we define as real, it also raises the question of which is more important.
    In the end, at least on an individual level, does it matter to the brain that it isn't actually living the life it thinks it does? Of course not. It treats those thoughts as its reality, complete with choices, happiness, sadness, and everything else you can imagine. The fact that it lives in the vat makes no difference to it. The reality that the brain sees is much more important than the actuality that the brain lives in.
    Very nice post, Daniel.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Daniel-your post is very interesting. I wrote about something very similar. The empiricism-rationalism debate is of utmost importance when considering the Matrix. Your thoughts about the definition of reality and Descartes' conceptualization of the evil, possessing demon in his First Meditation remind me of Aristotle's rationalist tabula rasa. Your fascinating question regarding the rationalist's possible questioning of the real world (even after they leave the Matrix) begs another interesting question: are we predisposed to our definitions of reality, along with our definitions of substance, color, and the forms Plato claims we have inside our heads? Postmodernism seems to recognize the inevitable human propensity to question the system one is in… how did Neo know he was in the matrix?

    Your entry makes me think of Hume and Kant, and their disputes over synthetic a priori experiences. Hume might venture to say one can know nothing of a leaf’s color unless they truly experience a leaf. After all, aren’t things like color relative? And how can we determine that a leaf is green, or even what green is, if we have not had a sense-based experience regarding that leaf? How could Neo know the Matrix exists without having an experience that would, through his senses, signal the experience of such a Matrix around him? The empiricist would claim any other method of gathering knowledge is impossible. Yet Immanuel Kant would, in a rather postmodern sense, argue otherwise.

    Are there any things we can pinpoint in the world that are synthetic and a priori? Someone like Neo or a postmodern citizen might turn to mathematics, geometry, computer code, or things that can be shown to be true independently from raw experience. Yet these things are supposedly tautologies, and are exempt from discussion, whine people like Berkeley, Locke, and Hume - especially in his analytic-synthetic distinction. But are they tautologies? The rationalist would claim that we need not experience mathematics to recognize certain identities, but that mathematics does not have a tautological nature by virtue of Godel’s Incompleteness Theorem and the like. So the tabula rasa is not as blank as we think it might be. Neo may be able to find his way out of a world of the Matrix analytically without experiencing a higher dimension of reality that might allow him to do so synthetically.

    ReplyDelete