Pages

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Blogging Around

Comment on Jacob Kahn's "Semester One - Skill Reflection":


Summary:
Jacob wrote about a significant, intellectual shift that described how he needed to maintain a delicate, subtle balance in maintaining and discarding material in his writing in order to progress.


Comment:
Jacob, while reading your blog, I was captivated by your powerful language, syntax, descriptive writing, and illustrative voice. I agreed completely because, coincidentally, I had a nearly identical, intellectual shift that, just like yours, involved the poetry unit as well as the change in mind, “I must be ready to discard material I am attached to in order to make progress in writing.” As I read about your shift, the catalyst, its applications, and other parameters regarding the change in mind, I fully connected to your thinking and tried to analyze some parallels that may exist in our similar experiences. Could our realizations be applied to other aspects of our lives, not only the literary world? Were you hesitant to adopt your change in mind, just like how I originally believed my shift to be counter-intuitive?


The analogy of the “balancing act” was outstanding. It articulated the essential question: What should I discard and maintain in my writing? It delineated the herculean tasks of identifying what to maintain and discard as well as letting go of ideas or writing material that one may think are perfect. Just like you, I went through a phase of satisfaction while writing the first couple of drafts of my poem, an aggregate of words abstractly put together--a piece of writing that I was only able to understand. Clearly, my beliefs were wrong, and I found that "cutting" did not hinder my progress; rather, it opens passageways to higher and more refined levels of thinking and writing. Yet, now, I try to apply the shift to writing assignments; however, I am constantly skeptical about whether or not it is comprehensible to others. My fear could potentially lead to an obsession of "cutting," which results in the regress of my work. I realized that I need external sources like my parents and teachers to provide objective advice on what I should cut and change. Yet, this is inconvenient, and I question the effectiveness of the shift itself. Am I not in the same, final position when I do "cut" with help from other sources as I write, perhaps, incomprehensible material and receive help for revision and rewriting? What should I do so that I can objectively "cut" and compose, on my own, a successful and understandable piece? And in some cases, where there is a huge wealth of information, which portions should I utilize?


And yet, I was amazed by the transition from the description of the shift to its applications to other English assignments such as the Orlando thesis essay and the Lear University essays. I agree that there should be a limit to what we do, even though we may be inclined to do more and more. The process of writing or any other process is always a staircase. I must be complete one single step to move on. However, I found that perhaps we may fall down the steps. But, as quoted from your blog, "We start with the knowledge of what we had done before, that makes every new creation of ours substantially more." 
__________________________________________________________________________________


Comment on Julia's "When Failure Reveals Growth":


Summary:
Julia discussed in her blog the frustration, panic, writer's block, and perfectionism associated with test-taking and writing. She articulated, through her experience of writing an original poem, that failure does reveal growth and that learning must be taken at a steady pace.


Comment:
Julia, while reading your blog, I thought that, by the absolute authenticity and clarity of your voice, you were talking to me in person, one-on-one. The great descriptions of the profound emotions that you experienced while taking the King Lear multiple choice test and formulating your original poem constructed a powerful case for reflection on the first semester of English. By placing myself into the “world” of your blog itself, I realized that your colloquial voice made way for a logical, understandable sequence from what you felt in dire situations to what you learned overall: a steady pace in learning is essential for being attentive to the complex world around us.  


In response to your blog, I reflected on my own experiences during English and found that numerous “voices” plagued my studying and learning as well. I felt the constant need to put on the clothing of the “perfectionist” while writing the first draft to a poem or an essay. Also, you clearly defined the difference between test-taking and writing with the perspective of, “Where is the extraction of myself and my voice necessary?” I frequently worried about the fact that tests and writing assignments were weighed equally, yet, took ample portions of the English grade. I did well on writing assignments and not so well on literature tests. I did well on my original poem, yet, I received a B on my poetry test, even though they coincide on the same topic, poetry. What’s the matter? Could your suggestion of “extracting myself” apply to that situation? Even though I fully appreciate the importance of discarding the multiple voices associated with anxiety and failure when writing and taking tests, what voices should I keep? I found that while you rewrote your poem, you allowed to story to come out and develop on its own rather than you forcing its maturing. Yet, would that be applicable to writing an academic essay? What would you suggest for eliminating the perfectionist mindset when writing, for example, a research paper?


Overall, you blog kindled a state of reflection on the first semester of English, and by learning about your experiences, I decided to take the insight of your lesson about maintaining a steady pace. I realized that the confidence that I receive from maximizing my learning while having a steady pace will form the basis of my success in both test taking and writing. 







No comments:

Post a Comment